Often whenever dates are offered, they are offered that have day of one’s month you to do maybe not match thereupon time whilst in genuine background. One such analogy happens in Harry Potter and the Prisoner regarding Azkaban whenever Sybill Trelawney makes reference to sixteen Oct since Saturday, regardless of if 16 Oct 1993 is a saturday.
There are also contradictions for the instructions in this region. Such as, for the Harry Potter and also the Goblet away from Fire, each other step 1 Sep and you can 2 Sep are offered because the Mondays and you can, within the Harry Potter as well as the Prisoner from Azkaban, Buckbeak’s demo is determined on 20 April, however, careful parsing of text message implies that it could has actually happened no later than simply February.
Plus, during the Harry Potter and Cup away from Flames it is said the Champions had been selected to the Tuesday 31 Oct, but 31 October is actually a saturday during the 1994.
For the chapter 7 of Quidditch From the Years, they say the very first Quidditch Globe Cup happened within the 1473. In the event the title are stored the four years, so it issues toward statement during the Cup out-of Flame the 1994 Business Mug is the brand new 422nd. If Quidditch From Ages is good, the 422nd Quidditch World Mug perform indeed fall in the year 3161, in case Cup of Flames excellent, the initial World Glass had been kept when you look at the 306.
Historical troubles [ ]
As the series, according to the timeline produced from the Chamber off Gifts resource, is determined in the nineties, the new collection will appears like it is set in the brand new later 1990s in order to mid-2000s, approximately concurrent into the guide of your own books. For the Harry Potter in addition to 1 / 2 of-Bloodstream Prince, Cornelius Fudge uses a male pronoun to mention to your “predecessor” of your Best Minister of your own United kingdom. Depending on the over schedule, this should take place in the summer months from 1996, if the Perfect Minister was John Significant, whoever quick predecessor is actually a female (‘s very first meeting with Fudge, the book mentions the latest election, but Big wasn’t 1st chose and just took more than once Thatcher retired.
It is possible, yet not impractical, one Fudge might possibly be speaing sД±cak Vietnamca kД±z frankly about an even more faraway predecessor, due to the fact Thatcher took place of work before Fudge allegedly became Minister getting Miracle. (Although one can possibly envision a scenario in which Fudge are delegated from the Minister having Magic to meet up on the Finest Minister while he, Fudge, was in a smaller sized workplace.) On the other hand, the identification and you will reputation for the prime Minister represented generally seems to alot more closely match that Tony Blair than out-of John Significant. A post in the Every day Send notes that Rowling are close on after that-Chancellor of Exchequer Gordon Brownish (tend to seen as a competition so you’re able to Blair’s management of your Labor Class, who been successful him and became Prime Minister), and therefore she might have been trying to inform you Blair’s bad front side. In case your books had been invest connect which have publication day out-of Philosopher’s Brick, then so it experiences do occur in 2002 (shortly after Blair became Primary Minister).
However, it had been later reported that twenty-two November try a tuesday, which it was a student in 1994
The same condition comes to Nicolas Flamel, who was stated as actually 665 in the course of new basic book, but Nicolas Flamel try a genuine historic profile and won’t have reached that many years up until 1996, around the big date the initial guide are had written. New rebuttal because of it is the fact that the go out the new “real” Nicolas Flamel was created cannot keep in touch with the new Nicolas Flamel out-of Harry Potter.
A different disease is obtainable off Rubeus Hagrid’s tenure due to the fact Hogwarts’s gamekeeper. It is meant on the collection one Hagrid was given one to standing in this many years out-of his expulsion regarding college during the 1942. In one scene from Harry Potter in addition to Cup of Flames, Molly Weasley reminisces in the Ogg, Hagrid’s preekeeper apparently convergence that have Molly’s age in school, it appears to be impractical one to she recalls a previous gamekeeper. Although not, it will be possible one Hagrid didn’t feel an effective gamekeeper immediately after getting expelled, but rather already been because Ogg’s secretary. This will be probable due to the fact when Harry thinks he have a tendency to getting expelled to have flying on broomstick in the place of permission inside the first 12 months, he secret in the event the he’d be allowed to stick to once the Hagrid’s assistant.